Conditional resignation at remote psychology clinic not a dismissal
A registered psychologist who resigned from a remote Western Australian psychology clinic, then set six conditions for withdrawing that resignation, was not dismissed when the employer ultimately accepted the resignation, the Fair Work Commission has found. In a decision issued on 12 October 2026, Deputy President Clancy dismissed the worker’s general protections application under s.365 of the Fair Work Act 2009 for want of jurisdiction, because no dismissal had occurred.
A resignation, a request to reconsider, and six conditions
The employer runs a private psychology clinic in remote Western Australia, with work flowing through NDIS, Medicare, Employee Assistance and private referral pathways. The worker started on 1 July 2024 as a part-time registered psychologist, working a two weeks on, two weeks off fly-in fly-out roster from her home in Victoria to Geraldton.
On Friday 3 October 2025 she emailed a resignation letter, saying she had reached the decision after careful consideration and that the company’s direction no longer aligned with her values. The letter raised nine issues. The following Monday, 6 October 2025, a director asked her to reconsider so the issues could be worked through. She replied the same day that she felt she had been put in a position where she had to resign but was open to reconsidering, and listed six action points: details of an investigation, adjustments to office lighting, back-pay to bring her pay up to 7.6 hours, outstanding superannuation, report templates and copies of her employee records.
Over the following days the employer provided a grievance lodgement form, undertook to review pay and entitlements, reported that a preliminary superannuation audit with its accountant and the ATO showed payments were up to date, offered lighting options, and confirmed it expected her back in Geraldton on 14 October 2025. On 10 October she said she would not attend the clinic and proposed working remotely from Melbourne. On Sunday 12 October she found herself locked out of her work laptop and asked whether she had been relieved of duties or terminated.
On 13 October 2025 the employer wrote that, as she had not confirmed an intention to rescind her resignation, it accepted the resignation of 3 October, assumed a final day of Friday 17 October 2025 based on her two weeks’ contractual notice, and would pay one week’s wages in lieu because she was not returning to Geraldton that week.
Why neither limb of the dismissal definition was made out
Under the Act, a person is dismissed if the employment is terminated at the employer’s initiative, or if the person resigned but was forced to do so by the employer’s conduct. The Commission found neither applied.
On the first limb, Deputy President Clancy was not persuaded the 13 October 2025 email terminated the employment at the employer’s initiative. Read against the wider correspondence, the employer had simply decided not to require any work over the final four days, 14 to 17 October 2025 inclusive, while still paying a week’s wages. The resignation itself was in writing, was not a heat of the moment act, and gave considered reasons.
On the second limb, the clearest sign the employer had not set out to end the employment was its own request, three days after the resignation, that the worker reconsider. The parties saw the lighting issue in sharply different terms and disagreed over the worker’s wish to audio record conversations, but the Commission found the employer had not shut down the dialogue. Deputy President Clancy accepted the working relationship could have run more smoothly, but did not accept that was solely the fault of the employer and its practice manager, finding the worker bore some responsibility too. He was satisfied the decision to resign came from her own fundamental unhappiness at work.
This is in fact a very sound reason for a resignation. No one is compelled and nor should they feel compelled to remain in a position of employment that makes them feel fundamentally unhappy.
Fair Work Commission, [2026] FWC 3893
The jurisdictional bar has since changed
The outcome turned on the law as it stood when the application was filed on 24 October 2025. Under that version of s.365, only a person who had in fact been dismissed could ask the Commission to deal with the dispute, so the dismissal question had to be resolved first. The decision notes that applications lodged on or after 7 July 2026 require only an allegation of dismissal, following the Workplace Relations Legislation Amendment (Building Cooperative Workplaces No. 1) Act 2026.
What this means for SCHADS employers
The decision shows the Commission treating a written, considered resignation as standing on its own feet, even where the departing worker later attaches conditions to staying and even where the employer locks out IT access and pays out part of the notice period. An employer’s genuine invitation to reconsider weighed against any finding of forced resignation, not in favour of it. The reasoning reaches any care operation, whether an allied health practice, a disability service, an aged care facility, a home care provider or a community services organisation, where a resignation arrives in the middle of an unresolved grievance. It also signals that for applications lodged from 7 July 2026, the same dispute would clear the jurisdictional gate on a mere allegation of dismissal, so the dismissal question would be contested later rather than at the threshold.
How we support SCHADS employers
General protections laws protect workers from adverse action based on protected attributes and conduct. We help our clients build workplaces where these protections are embedded in everyday management practice.
We support our clients by ensuring that:
- employment decisions about hiring, promotion, pay and termination are based on genuine work-related factors and documented consistently
- managers understand which attributes and forms of conduct attract protection, and how to distinguish lawful performance management from unlawful adverse action
- complaints and concerns about potential breaches are handled promptly through fair processes that give affected workers a genuine opportunity to respond
- policies and procedures are applied uniformly so that similarly situated workers are treated the same way
SCHADS Award questions? 1800 SCHADS are Australia’s SCHADS Award specialists. The first call is obligation free: a scoping conversation about where you stand on sleepovers, on-call work, broken shifts, classifications and wage audits. Call 1800 SCHADS (1800 724 237).
Source reference: [2026] FWC 3893
A SCHADS question of your own?
The first call is obligation free, confidential, and with an actual SCHADS specialist.