Unfair dismissal

Employer’s termination emails amounted to dismissal, Commission finds

← Back to SCHADS news

An employer’s own emails, telling a worker’s representative that it had decided to terminate his services, amounted to a dismissal at the employer’s initiative, the Fair Work Commission has found. The decision, issued on 29 October 2026 in [2026] FWC 4046, dismissed the employer’s jurisdictional objection (a preliminary argument that the Commission has no power to hear the claim) and defeated its argument that the worker had resigned at a meeting a week earlier. The worker’s unfair dismissal application under s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 will now proceed. The decision is subject to confidentiality orders.

How the dispute arose

The employer is a non-profit religious association run by a management committee. The applicant had worked for it as a priest without a break from at least 7 May 2024, and had held the same position on and off since 2017. In October 2025 the association learned of serious allegations about his conduct and instructed him to stay away from work. Meetings followed on 31 October and 24 November 2025. The applicant’s English is limited, and the first meeting went ahead without a professional interpreter.

At the 24 November meeting, the applicant’s representative indicated on his behalf that he was resigning. The association’s own later email described this as a verbal proposal to resign, subject to a mutual deed of release (an agreement in which the parties give up future legal claims against each other) and the payment of six months’ salary.

Settlement negotiations followed by email. On 29 November 2025, the association wrote that its committee had determined to terminate the applicant’s employment. On 1 December 2025, it wrote that, having decided to terminate his services for misconduct, it could not continue to discuss other terms, and that if its offer was not accepted that day he would remain terminated as from 30 November 2025. On 3 December 2025, it sent a resignation letter for him to sign. He did not sign it. Instead, on 5 December 2025, his representative emailed a resignation backdated to 30 November, saying he felt he had been left with no practical option but to cease in his role. On 6 December 2025, the association accepted the resignation, declined to pay any gratuity because the resignation contained no release from further claims, and told him to leave the accommodation it provided straight away.

What the Commission decided

The association argued the applicant resigned at the 24 November meeting, and its three witnesses each said the resignation was accepted there, while conceding that none of them could approve the payment he sought. The applicant maintained that no resignation occurred that day and that he was instead forced to resign on 5 December 2025.

Commissioner Tran found there was no effective resignation on 24 November 2025. Assessed objectively, the applicant had offered to resign only on terms that were still being negotiated, and his employment remained on foot while the employer considered its position. The evidence showed the committee was divided on whether to accept the resignation and the proposal, and the witness with carriage of the matter did not regard the resignation as effective without a written letter. That witness said the board and congregation were frustrated by the delay and wanted the matter done, which was why the termination wording was used.

The Commission held that the paragraphs recording the association’s decision to terminate were not offers to resolve the dispute, and so were not protected as without prejudice correspondence (settlement communications that ordinarily cannot be used as evidence).

This clearly terminated the applicant’s employment and did so upon the employer’s initiative,

Fair Work Commission, [2026] FWC 4046

The dismissal took effect on 30 November 2025. The 5 December resignation was ineffective because the applicant had already been dismissed, and the Commissioner found for completeness that it would in any event have been a forced resignation under s.386(1) of the Act, which treats a resignation as a dismissal where the employer’s conduct forced it.

The decision dealt only with whether the applicant was dismissed. No finding has yet been made on whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable, and the matter will be listed for case management.

What this means for community services providers

The principle binds every employer, including disability, home care and community services providers. When an employee offers to resign on conditions that are still being negotiated, the employment continues until the terms are settled, and a written communication stating that the organisation has decided to terminate can itself constitute a dismissal, whatever label the parties later attach. Exit negotiations in this sector are often handled by a coordinator or a small back-office team rather than specialist HR staff, and conducted largely by email with workers who may be rostered across clients’ homes and hard to meet in person. The decision shows that the question of who ended the employment is answered objectively from those communications, not from what either side intended them to mean.

How we support SCHADS employers

Unfair dismissal claims can expose employers to significant legal and operational risk. We help our clients build robust dismissal practices that protect both the organisation and the employee.

We support our clients by ensuring that:

  • dismissal decisions are preceded by a fair process that gives the employee a genuine opportunity to respond to performance or conduct concerns
  • documentation of performance or conduct issues is thorough and contemporaneous, supporting any decision to dismiss
  • the reason for dismissal is substantive and the decision is not harsh, unjust or unreasonable in the circumstances
  • procedural fairness is observed, including consideration of whether the employee has access to support or representation during any hearing

SCHADS Award questions? 1800 SCHADS are Australia’s SCHADS Award specialists. The first call is obligation free: a scoping conversation about where you stand on sleepovers, on-call work, broken shifts, classifications and wage audits. Call 1800 SCHADS (1800 724 237).

Source reference: [2026] FWC 4046

A SCHADS question of your own?

The first call is obligation free, confidential, and with an actual SCHADS specialist.

Call 1800 SCHADS Book a scoping meeting
Wage audits Sleepovers Classifications Self-Managed NDIS
← All SCHADS news

Start the conversation

Not ready to call? Leave your details and a SCHADS specialist will come back to you.