Flexible workingOn-call and recallRostering

Fair Work Commission backs refusal of nurse’s flexible work request

← Back to SCHADS news

The Fair Work Commission has dismissed a dispute brought by an anaesthetic registered nurse over her private hospital employer’s refusal of a flexible working arrangement request, in a decision issued on 7 August 2026 ([2026] FWC 2350). Commissioner Simpson found the request was validly made under the Fair Work Act 2009, but that the employer had reasonable business grounds to refuse it, in part because four of the nurse’s colleagues already held flexible arrangements built around Fridays.

The request and the roster pressure behind the refusal

The nurse, employed since 16 December 2013, works a seven-day rotating roster and participates in after-hours, weekend and public holiday on-call duties. On 10 November 2025 she lodged a written flexible working request relying on the circumstance that she is aged 55 or older, asking to work Monday to Thursday with Fridays rostered off. She offered to stay flexible about shifts in peak periods and to remain available for all on-call rosters.

The unit’s nurse manager refused the request verbally on 27 November 2025, and a series of alternatives followed: weekend-focused on-call shifts with one extended three-day weekend a month where operationally feasible, a four-week pattern of a Monday off, then two Wednesdays, then a Friday, and finally every Wednesday rostered off, which the nurse declined. Her counter-proposal of every Monday off was also denied.

The anaesthetics unit has 17 permanent nurses, equating to 12.7 full-time equivalent staff, with casual and agency cover for the daily shortfall. A typical Friday calls for 14 to 18 anaesthetic nursing staff and 12 to 16 post-anaesthetic care staff. Of the four nurses with existing Friday-related arrangements, two have every Friday off, one has every second Friday off and one has a monthly Friday off.

Valid request, but reasonable business grounds to refuse

The employer contested whether the request was validly made at all, arguing the nurse had given shifting rationales for it and had produced no medical information. Commissioner Simpson rejected that threshold argument, finding a qualifying circumstance applied and that there was

a relevant causal connection between that circumstance and the request

Fair Work Commission, [2026] FWC 2350

The refusal nevertheless stood. The Commission accepted evidence of an existing shortage of trained anaesthetic nurses, and that Fridays bring

higher acuity patients spanning across speciality areas which require a higher level of speciality coverage

Fair Work Commission, [2026] FWC 2350

The Commission also accepted that

the existence of other pre-existing flexible work arrangements has created a particular problem in relation to a further reduction in trained anaesthetic nurse availability on Fridays

Fair Work Commission, [2026] FWC 2350

The Act permits an employer to refuse such a request only where it has discussed the request with the employee, genuinely tried to reach agreement, had regard to the consequences of refusal for the employee, and refused on reasonable business grounds. Commissioner Simpson found the employer had made genuine efforts to settle on an agreed alternative, and noted its continuing practice of trying to keep the nurse free on Fridays where it could, an outcome achieved in most weeks but not assured.

A dismissal with an expectation attached

The employer told the Commission that once further recruitment of trained anaesthetic nurses is complete, it will be in a position to agree to the request. Three permanent staff started in January 2026 but were still completing a novice nurse program and could not yet be allocated independently. Commissioner Simpson concluded:

I expect that the Applicant’s request will be able to be accommodated at the time this further recruitment occurs and sufficient staffing is obtained.

Fair Work Commission, [2026] FWC 2350

The dispute was filed on 23 January 2026 and went to hearing in Brisbane after conferences failed to resolve it. The refusal was found to be on reasonable business grounds at this time, on staffing conditions the employer said it expects to change.

What this means for SCHADS employers

The decision shows the Commission treating a genuine shortage of specialist clinical staff, compounded by flexible arrangements already granted to colleagues, as reasonable business grounds to refuse a further request, even where the request itself is validly made. That reasoning reaches any care operation rostering scarce skilled staff across a seven-day service, whether in aged care, disability, home care or community services. It also shows that reasonable business grounds are assessed at a point in time: the Commission recorded an express expectation that the request would be accommodated once recruitment lifted staffing levels, signalling that a refusal grounded in a temporary shortage may not hold once conditions change.

How we support SCHADS employers

On-call and recall arrangements are common in aged care, disability support and community services, but they need careful management to comply with modern employment law and support workforce wellbeing. We help our clients design and operate these arrangements fairly and lawfully.

We support our clients by ensuring that:

  • on-call and recall policies clearly set out what being on-call means, when recall can occur, how recall is triggered, and what pay or time off applies
  • agreements about on-call work are documented in writing and discussed with staff before arrangements begin
  • on-call periods do not place such restrictions on an employee’s personal time that they effectively become paid work, and the policy distinguishes between true on-call (remaining available) and standby work
  • staff who are recalled to work are paid for the time they actually work, and any time-off allowance for unsocial hours is provided as agreed
  • records are kept of on-call rosters and actual recall instances so that arrangements can be reviewed and adjusted if they become unreasonable

SCHADS Award questions? 1800 SCHADS are Australia’s SCHADS Award specialists. The first call is obligation free: a scoping conversation about where you stand on sleepovers, on-call work, broken shifts, classifications and wage audits. Call 1800 SCHADS (1800 724 237).

Source reference: [2026] FWC 2350

A SCHADS question of your own?

The first call is obligation free, confidential, and with an actual SCHADS specialist.

Call 1800 SCHADS Book a scoping meeting
Wage audits Sleepovers Classifications Self-Managed NDIS
← All SCHADS news

Start the conversation

Not ready to call? Leave your details and a SCHADS specialist will come back to you.