Fair Work Commission refuses interim order halting discipline
The Fair Work Commission has refused to make interim orders pausing an employer’s disciplinary process while a stop-bullying application was still on foot ([2025] FWC 2521). The decision confirms that a worker seeking an interim stop-bullying order must actually satisfy the Commission that bullying has occurred and that the risk is continuing. Showing an arguable case and arguing the balance of convenience is not enough. The ruling binds all employers, whatever award covers them.
What happened
A worker filed a stop-bullying application on 11 July 2025 against his employer and four individuals, including his manager. Conciliation on 7 August 2025 did not resolve the matter. On 19 August 2025 the employer issued a show cause letter and advised that termination of his employment was under serious consideration.
The letter raised three allegations: smoking during a Microsoft Teams meeting while working from home in November 2024, a group-chat message from February 2025, and a poll the worker created in a team chat on 11 August 2025, viewable by 54 staff, asking colleagues whether he should give up or keep fighting his bullying claim. The poll referred to the four individuals named in his application.
On 26 August 2025 the worker sought interim orders restraining the employer from dismissing or disciplining him until the substantive application was decided. The employer put its process on hold pending the ruling, and the matter was decided on the papers.
Why the Commission refused
Applying Full Bench authority, the Commission held it can make an interim stop-bullying order only if actually satisfied the worker has been bullied at work and that the bullying is at risk of continuing. Neither requirement was met. The Commission also found it had no power to make an interim order restraining adverse action, because no general protections application was before it.
On the bullying allegations, the Commission found:
- a one-off group-chat comment by a colleague, later retracted, was not repeated unreasonable behaviour
- a request that the worker update his status to show whether he was working from home appeared to be a simple misunderstanding, not excessive scrutiny
- allegations against the manager largely concerned performance feedback, which was not shown to be anything other than reasonable management action
Nor was the show cause letter itself bullying. While the Commission queried why smoking at home during a meeting would warrant a disciplinary letter, and observed a formal letter over the group-chat message might be seen by some as an overreaction, the poll was fresh conduct.
“I cannot understand why the Applicant would think that the poll was a good idea,”
Fair Work Commission, [2025] FWC 2521
The Commission noted the employer rightly raised concerns about the named individuals being brought into disrepute in front of 54 colleagues.
On continuing risk, the worker had not been at the workplace for four months and was on unpaid leave. His most recent medical certificate, dated 28 April 2025, referred only to a medical condition, and he had indicated he would not provide a clearance certificate until the workplace changed. His workers compensation claim had been rejected on the basis the injury arose out of reasonable management action. On that evidence the Commission was not satisfied he would return to the workplace, and therefore not satisfied any risk of bullying continued.
The interim application was dismissed. The substantive stop-bullying application remains to be heard, and the Commission noted its conclusions may change with further evidence at a final hearing.
What this means for care and community services providers
The principle applies to every employer, including disability, home care and community services providers. A disciplinary process can lawfully run alongside a stop-bullying application unless the Commission is actually satisfied that bullying has occurred and is at risk of continuing, a materially higher bar than the usual test for interim orders. That matters in a sector where small back-office teams often handle a Commission matter and an internal performance process at the same time, and where group chats used to coordinate rosters across clients’ homes and community sites can become the setting for exactly the kind of conduct examined here.
How we support SCHADS employers
Workplace bullying damages culture, retention and wellbeing across social and community services organisations. We help our clients build workplaces where respectful behaviour is the norm and concerns are handled fairly.
We support our clients by ensuring that:
- clear conduct standards and values are communicated to all staff so everyone understands what respectful workplace behaviour looks like
- managers and supervisors can recognise bullying behaviour and understand how to respond proportionately when concerns arise
- staff have safe, accessible channels to raise concerns about bullying without fear of retaliation, and those reports are investigated fairly and promptly
- workplaces have processes to support both affected staff and workgroups after bullying incidents, focusing on repair and prevention of recurrence
SCHADS Award questions? 1800 SCHADS are Australia’s SCHADS Award specialists. The first call is obligation free: a scoping conversation about where you stand on sleepovers, on-call work, broken shifts, classifications and wage audits. Call 1800 SCHADS (1800 724 237).
Source reference: [2025] FWC 2521
A SCHADS question of your own?
The first call is obligation free, confidential, and with an actual SCHADS specialist.