Fair Work Commission upholds dismissal for misleading investigators
In a decision issued on 2 November 2026, the Fair Work Commission dismissed an unfair dismissal claim by a senior home lender on a $250,000 base salary, finding he intentionally misled his employer’s whistleblowing investigators and then sought to mislead the Commission itself. Deputy President Boyce found all four allegations against the worker substantiated and held the dismissal was not unfair.
The worker held the most senior of the bank’s three lender levels from 16 November 2020 until his dismissal on 29 July 2025. Although his income was well above the high income threshold, he was covered by an enterprise agreement and could therefore bring the claim under the Fair Work Act 2009.
An anonymous tip led to a wider review
The matter began with an anonymous report to the bank’s internal whistleblowing program on 19 November 2024. A preliminary inquiry cleared the worker, but the bank broadened its investigation to include a sample of loans he had processed that were refinanced from his previous employer.
Many of those customers were self-employed and had been referred under the bank’s referral program, in which accredited partners such as accountants and lawyers earn commission on approved loans. Mortgage brokers are excluded from the program. The customers had come through two accredited partners and had supplied financial documents prepared by the same accounting firm. The investigation found five customers made payments totalling $48,595.50 to an unaccredited third party, whom one customer described as their mortgage broker, and the two partners paid the same man $81,146.44 and $61,441.62 respectively, with descriptions including “service fee” and “referral fee”. The bank removed both partners from the program in April 2025.
Three allegations admitted, one denied
The bank put four allegations to the worker on 11 June 2025. Two concerned loan applications in August 2024 in which he recorded customers as self-employed and omitted their PAYG wage income, contrary to the bank’s income verification procedure. He told investigators he “forgot” and was “lazy to verify the PAYG income”.
A third allegation was that he shared customer loan updates on WeChat, an unapproved messaging app, in a group chat with an accredited referrer and the unaccredited third party, contrary to a procedure barring staff from using a personal phone to deal with customers on business matters. He said he had already deleted the chat.
The final and contested allegation was that he intentionally misled investigators at a first interview on 14 May 2025 by claiming he had “no idea” who the third party was. His work phone held a saved contact for the man and text messages in which a customer thanked the worker and the man together. At a second interview on 27 May 2025 he accepted he knew him, and later claimed he had known the man only by a Chinese nickname.
Deputy President Boyce found the worker “knew exactly who” the man was at the first interview “but thought he could get away with pretending otherwise”, and described the nickname account as “not only unbridled nonsense, but a complete fabrication”.
“I find that the Applicant’s evidence at the hearing was a chaotic collection of lies, nonsense, poorly matched ideas, and manufactured responses.”
Fair Work Commission, [2026] FWC 4224
The Commission rejected “each and every assertion” by the worker minimising his conduct and found the resulting loss of trust and confidence was a valid reason for dismissal.
An industry list and notice pay did not help the worker
The worker argued his dismissal was harsh because his name had been placed on an industry background check list, meaning other banks will be told of his dismissal and the reasons for it. The Commission did not accept that this weighed towards harshness.
“Absent a term in a deed of release or separation agreement, there is no law against an employer telling another employer/s that an employee has been dismissed for misconduct,”
Fair Work Commission, [2026] FWC 4224
The Deputy President added that employers in an industry centralising such a list was “equally unextraordinary”.
The worker also argued that being paid in lieu of notice undermined the bank’s position that his misconduct justified immediate dismissal. The Commission rejected that contention entirely, finding the payment was within the employer’s sole discretion: “It undermines nothing, and is an admission of nothing.”
On process, the worker had 24 hours’ notice of each interview, was offered a support person each time and declined, received a show cause letter on 11 July 2025 and responded on 15 July 2025. The Commission found “no procedural deficiencies (at all)” and dismissed the application.
What this means for community services providers
The principles here are award-neutral and reach every employer, including disability, home care and community services providers. The decision confirms that dishonesty during an internal investigation can itself found a valid reason for dismissal, separate from the conduct originally under review, and that neither payment in lieu of notice nor the prospect of an industry reference check makes an otherwise sound dismissal harsh. Those points land in a sector where support work happens in clients’ homes, personal phones are often the easiest channel for client updates, and investigations are frequently run by small back-office teams rather than specialist HR staff, and where worker screening and portable reference checks already circulate the reasons for a dismissal between providers.
How we support SCHADS employers
Unfair dismissal claims can expose employers to significant legal and operational risk. We help our clients build robust dismissal practices that protect both the organisation and the employee.
We support our clients by ensuring that:
- dismissal decisions are preceded by a fair process that gives the employee a genuine opportunity to respond to performance or conduct concerns
- documentation of performance or conduct issues is thorough and contemporaneous, supporting any decision to dismiss
- the reason for dismissal is substantive and the decision is not harsh, unjust or unreasonable in the circumstances
- procedural fairness is observed, including consideration of whether the employee has access to support or representation during any hearing
SCHADS Award questions? 1800 SCHADS are Australia’s SCHADS Award specialists. The first call is obligation free: a scoping conversation about where you stand on sleepovers, on-call work, broken shifts, classifications and wage audits. Call 1800 SCHADS (1800 724 237).
Source reference: [2026] FWC 4224
A SCHADS question of your own?
The first call is obligation free, confidential, and with an actual SCHADS specialist.