General protectionsUnderpayment

Financial hardship not exceptional circumstances for late claim

← Back to SCHADS news

The Fair Work Commission has refused to grant a former employee of a counselling and support services provider extra time to lodge a general protections dismissal application, in a decision issued on 4 September 2026 finding that financial distress after losing a job is not unusual enough to meet the statutory test for exceptional circumstances ([2026] FWC 3384).

Deputy President O’Keeffe determined the matter on the papers in Perth. The application was made under s.365 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), which allows a person who alleges they were dismissed in contravention of the Act’s general protections to apply to the Commission. Such applications have a 21-day time limit, and the applicant accepted his was lodged late. An extension is only available under s.366(2):

The FWC may allow a further period if the FWC is satisfied that there are exceptional circumstances, taking into account: (a) the reason for the delay; and (b) any action taken by the person to dispute the dismissal; and (c) prejudice to the employer (including prejudice caused by the delay); and (d) the merits of the application; and (e) fairness as between the person and other persons in a like position.

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), s.366(2)

The worker’s explanation for the delay

The applicant held a sponsored visa tied to the role, and said the dismissal left him owed wages and entitlements he depended on for rent, bills and daily living costs. He said the loss of the job put his ability to remain in Australia at serious risk, forcing him to urgently seek alternative sponsorship, borrow money and reorganise his finances. At the same time he was pursuing the unpaid wages through the Industrial Magistrates Court, where he had difficulty serving documents on the employer, and said he was managing complex legal processes without representation and under significant stress.

Why the explanation fell short

The Commission worked through each element of that account. Arguments based on self-representation and not knowing the correct legal avenue had been put to the Commission many times before and refused, and were refused again. Consistent Commission authority holds that mental distress does not establish exceptional circumstances, and direct negotiation with a former employer does not assist either.

On the court proceedings, Deputy President O’Keeffe noted the applicant had managed to prepare an affidavit and claim documents and attempt service on the employer.

It is unclear why, in being capable of doing this, he was incapable of lodging his application with the FWC at the same time.

Fair Work Commission, [2026] FWC 3384

On financial hardship, the decision adopted earlier Commission reasoning, upheld on appeal, that financial distress following the loss of employment and its income cannot be described as uncommon, special or unusual.

The outcome

The reason for the delay counted against an extension, and the other four statutory considerations were treated as neutral. The applicant had pressed the underpayment with the employer but had not clearly contested the dismissal itself. Prejudice to the employer was hard to gauge because the company had gone into liquidation before the file was allocated, and in any event an absence of prejudice would not itself establish exceptional circumstances. No finding was made on the merits because the evidence had not been tested, and no person in a like position was identified. The liquidator did not oppose the matter continuing but could not make submissions, and no one else came forward to act for the company.

I have assessed the five matters set out in the Act. Four of them are neutral and the remaining matter weighs against a finding of exceptional circumstances.

Fair Work Commission, [2026] FWC 3384

The application was dismissed as out of time, with an order to issue. The decision also records that a respondent’s liquidation does not stop the Commission from determining an extension of time application, and that pursuing an underpayment claim in another jurisdiction does not, of itself, explain a failure to lodge with the Commission within 21 days.

What this means for SCHADS employers

The decision shows the Commission holding firmly to its established line that the ordinary consequences of dismissal, including lost income, financial strain and visa pressure for sponsored workers, do not amount to exceptional circumstances justifying a late general protections claim. For aged care, disability, home care and community services operations, many of which employ sponsored visa holders, it confirms that the 21-day limit is applied strictly even where a dismissed worker faces genuine hardship. It also demonstrates that an employer’s liquidation neither prevents the Commission from deciding such an application nor tips the balance toward granting an extension.

How we support SCHADS employers

General protections laws protect workers from adverse action based on protected attributes and conduct. We help our clients build workplaces where these protections are embedded in everyday management practice.

We support our clients by ensuring that:

  • employment decisions about hiring, promotion, pay and termination are based on genuine work-related factors and documented consistently
  • managers understand which attributes and forms of conduct attract protection, and how to distinguish lawful performance management from unlawful adverse action
  • complaints and concerns about potential breaches are handled promptly through fair processes that give affected workers a genuine opportunity to respond
  • policies and procedures are applied uniformly so that similarly situated workers are treated the same way

SCHADS Award questions? 1800 SCHADS are Australia’s SCHADS Award specialists. The first call is obligation free: a scoping conversation about where you stand on sleepovers, on-call work, broken shifts, classifications and wage audits. Call 1800 SCHADS (1800 724 237).

Source reference: [2026] FWC 3384

A SCHADS question of your own?

The first call is obligation free, confidential, and with an actual SCHADS specialist.

Call 1800 SCHADS Book a scoping meeting
Wage audits Sleepovers Classifications Self-Managed NDIS
← All SCHADS news

Start the conversation

Not ready to call? Leave your details and a SCHADS specialist will come back to you.