Former-name checks in health recruitment ruled indirect discrimination
In a decision handed down on 16 September 2026, the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal found that a state health employer’s practice of disclosing an internal job applicant’s former names to people involved in hiring amounted to indirect discrimination on transgender grounds, and ordered the employer to pay the worker $35,000 within 60 days. The award, made under the Anti-Discrimination Act 1977 (NSW), comprised $25,000 in compensation for non-economic loss and $10,000 in aggravated damages.
The worker, a social worker employed in the NSW Health Service since 2020, is a transgender man who began transitioning in early 2012 and formally changed his first and middle names around that year. His identity is suppressed and the Tribunal referred to him by a pseudonym.
How the check worked
Under the recruitment procedure, which the Tribunal called the Former Name Check Condition, an internal applicant’s former names were sent to the convenor of the hiring process for the role, and often to another person close to the position, so validation and service checks could be done. This happened even though written policy allocated the task to a centralised People and Culture unit.
In June 2023, after the worker successfully applied for a temporary coordinator role, a support services officer telephoned him at work to confirm he had previously used his birth names. He had not been told during recruitment that people in his workplace would be given those names. He raised the issue internally several times over the following year, received no reply from the district’s human resources manager, and eventually complained to the NSW Ombudsman and Anti-Discrimination NSW in 2024.
During the Ombudsman’s investigation, the employer said the worker had been given an explanation and had raised nothing further. The Tribunal was blunt about that account:
This, we find, was untrue.
NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal, [2026] NSWCATAD 278
The Tribunal also found that a phone call the district’s chief executive said had closed the complaint never occurred.
Why the requirement was not reasonable
The employer argued the check was reasonable because the protection of patients and children is paramount, and the point was contested at hearing. The Tribunal accepted that complying with the condition
would create a real risk that he would be ‘outed’ to others as a transgender man in his workplace
NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal, [2026] NSWCATAD 278
and held that a plausible fear of humiliation was enough to establish an inability to comply. Critically, the same verification purpose could be achieved by confining the check to a centralised unit, without any costly, lengthy or complicated change. The Tribunal observed of the procedure:
It is there in the Statewide set of procedures NSW Health applies, and despite its discriminatory effect it remains there despite having no practical use in its application to someone in the position of the Applicant.
NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal, [2026] NSWCATAD 278
The Tribunal noted internal recognition of the problem: a letter from the district’s director of people and culture acknowledged that using a person’s birth name in this way could inadvertently disclose their transgender or gender diverse status to colleagues, and that knowledge of that risk could deter people from applying for positions. An internal committee brief in March 2025 nonetheless recommended retaining the current system and reminding staff of confidentiality.
The compensation and the aggravated damages
The worker sought $45,000 in general damages and was awarded $25,000. His evidence of ongoing anxiety, disturbed sleep and panic symptoms, and of being deterred from applying for at least two advertised roles since June 2023, was largely unchallenged. The Tribunal rejected the argument that the absence of medical evidence was fatal:
the harm caused by discrimination is not required to rise to the level of diagnosable psychiatric harm in order to be compensable
NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal, [2026] NSWCATAD 278
A further $10,000 in aggravated damages, against the $20,000 sought, flowed from the way the employer ran its case. The Tribunal identified two passages in the employer’s written submissions, one that its own solicitor could not sensibly explain despite being asked several times, and another accusing the worker of dishonesty over document redactions, an assertion the Tribunal found was and always was entirely without foundation, since the redactions were made to comply with the Tribunal’s own identity-protection orders.
Orders restraining the procedure were refused, the Tribunal seeing no real purpose in enjoining a very substantial government agency and noting evidence that the procedure had been under review since 2025. A late request for an apology was also refused as tokenistic coming from a state institution rather than a natural person. The procedure itself, which dates from 2017 and applies across a system that recorded 670,000 applications for 54,000 jobs posted in July 2024, is undisturbed by the orders.
What this means for SCHADS employers
The decision shows a tribunal treating an apparently neutral identity-verification step as indirect discrimination where it exposes a transgender worker to being outed, and where a less intrusive centralised alternative exists. The reasoning reaches any care or community services operation that verifies former names or aliases during recruitment or screening, whether in aged care, disability, home care or community services, and whether the check is applied to external candidates or internal movers. It also shows that the conduct of a discrimination case itself, including unfounded attacks on a complainant’s honesty, can attract aggravated damages on top of compensation.
How we support SCHADS employers
Discrimination in the workplace harms individuals, damages organisational culture, and creates legal exposure. We help our clients build workplaces where fair treatment is embedded in systems and practice.
We support our clients by ensuring that:
- policies and procedures clearly define unlawful discrimination and set out the standards expected of all staff members
- recruitment, promotion and termination decisions are based on documented, job-related criteria applied consistently across similar roles and circumstances
- managers receive training on recognising discrimination, unconscious bias, and their obligations under employment law
- workers have accessible channels to raise concerns about discriminatory treatment, and those concerns are investigated promptly and impartially
SCHADS Award questions? 1800 SCHADS are Australia’s SCHADS Award specialists. The first call is obligation free: a scoping conversation about where you stand on sleepovers, on-call work, broken shifts, classifications and wage audits. Call 1800 SCHADS (1800 724 237).
A SCHADS question of your own?
The first call is obligation free, confidential, and with an actual SCHADS specialist.