Full Bench quashes certificate over unresolved dismissal objection
A blank tick box on a Fair Work Commission response form did not cost an employer its objection that a worker resigned rather than being dismissed. In a decision handed down on 21 October 2026, a Full Bench of the Commission quashed a certificate issued in the worker’s general protections dispute and sent the matter back to the Commissioner to decide the dismissal question first. The ruling applies to employers generally, whatever award covers them.
How the dispute arose
The worker applied on 23 June 2026 under s 365 of the Fair Work Act 2009 for the Commission to deal with a general protections dispute involving dismissal. She alleged she had been constructively dismissed, that this was adverse action under s 342(1) taken because she had exercised workplace rights, contrary to s 340, and that other adverse action not involving dismissal had also occurred. The respondents were the employer and an individual.
In its Form F8A response, filed on 7 July 2026, the employer contended that the worker had resigned of her own volition and that the application was jurisdictionally flawed. Question 5.1 of the form asks whether the respondent objects to a conference on jurisdictional grounds, and warns that if the section is not completed the Commission will organise a conference and issue a certificate if the matter is not resolved. The employer ticked neither the yes box nor the no box, but in answer to question 5.2 stated that the applicant was not dismissed and had resigned of her own volition.
A staff conciliator conducted a conference on 9 September 2026 and the matter did not settle. The worker’s solicitors asked for a certificate on 10 September 2026, and the employer’s solicitors objected that same day, saying the dismissal objection had to be decided before any certificate could issue. The Commissioner issued the certificate under s 368(3) on 14 September 2026 and declined to revoke it the next day, on the basis that the employer had not elected to pursue its objection through question 5.1 and had instead chosen to participate in the conference. The appeal was filed on 23 September 2026.
The Full Bench’s reasoning
The Full Bench, comprising Vice President Gibian, Deputy President Wright and Deputy President Grayson, accepted the employer’s argument. Applying an earlier Full Federal Court authority, it held that a dispute about whether a person was dismissed raises a threshold issue going to the existence of the Commission’s power to compel an employer to participate in its conciliation processes, and that question had to be determined before a certificate could issue.
Despite the blank tick box, the Full Bench found the response form made clear that whether the worker had been dismissed was in dispute, and that nothing that followed could be construed as a concession. The matter had presumably been listed for conference without the dismissal issue being decided because of the unanswered question, and the Full Bench said it should not have been. Attendance at the conference did not indicate the employer had abandoned its position, and nothing the parties did could remove the need for the Commission to be satisfied a dismissal had occurred before exercising its s 368 powers.
“The parties’ consent cannot clothe the Commission with jurisdiction it does not have”
the Full Bench, [2026] FWCFB 283
Permission to appeal was granted under s 604 in the public interest. The Full Bench observed that a certificate that was not validly issued would be liable to be quashed by a court, leaving the parties to return to the Commission at a still later time. The decision, [2026] FWCFB 283, was determined on the papers and delivered in Sydney on 21 October 2026.
A narrowing window for this kind of dispute
The Full Bench noted that the Workplace Relations Legislation Amendment (Building Cooperative Workplaces No 1) Act 2026 replaced s 365. Under the new section, a person who simply alleges they were dismissed may apply, a change that applies to applications made on or after 7 July 2026. The earlier requirement, that the applicant had in fact been dismissed, governs applications lodged before that date, including this one. The worker’s application has been remitted to the Commissioner so the dismissal question can be determined.
What this means for community services providers
The principle binds every employer, including disability, home care and community services providers. Resignation disputes of this kind arise readily in the sector, where a support worker rostered across clients’ homes may resign to a coordinator after a rostering or pay disagreement and later contend the resignation was forced. Providers with small back-office teams often complete Commission response forms without specialist help, and this decision confirms that an objection stated clearly in the substance of the form is not lost through an unticked box. It also confirms that, for applications lodged before 7 July 2026, a contested dismissal question had to be resolved before the Commission could certify a general protections dispute.
How we support SCHADS employers
General protections laws protect workers from adverse action based on protected attributes and conduct. We help our clients build workplaces where these protections are embedded in everyday management practice.
We support our clients by ensuring that:
- employment decisions about hiring, promotion, pay and termination are based on genuine work-related factors and documented consistently
- managers understand which attributes and forms of conduct attract protection, and how to distinguish lawful performance management from unlawful adverse action
- complaints and concerns about potential breaches are handled promptly through fair processes that give affected workers a genuine opportunity to respond
- policies and procedures are applied uniformly so that similarly situated workers are treated the same way
SCHADS Award questions? 1800 SCHADS are Australia’s SCHADS Award specialists. The first call is obligation free: a scoping conversation about where you stand on sleepovers, on-call work, broken shifts, classifications and wage audits. Call 1800 SCHADS (1800 724 237).
Source reference: [2026] FWCFB 283
A SCHADS question of your own?
The first call is obligation free, confidential, and with an actual SCHADS specialist.