Full Bench refuses permission to appeal unfair dismissal decision
A Full Bench of the Fair Work Commission has refused a former bank employee permission to appeal against the dismissal of his unfair dismissal application, confirming the high bar that applies before an unsuccessful claim can be re-run on appeal. The ruling binds all employers and employees, whatever award or industry they fall under.
The claim and the first decision
The worker had been employed for 28 months and spent 9 of those months under performance intervention. The Commission dismissed his unfair dismissal claim on 17 April 2026 ([2026] FWC 1321), finding there was a valid reason for the dismissal, namely underperformance in the higher functions of the role and some underperformance in other functions covered by a performance improvement plan. The Commission also found the worker had been given an opportunity to respond to the employer’s concerns and had been warned about his unsatisfactory performance, concluding he was not suited to the role. Those findings followed the checklist in s 387 of the Fair Work Act 2009 for deciding whether a dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable.
The appeal
The worker appealed under s 604. Because the original decision was an unfair dismissal decision under Part 3-2 of the Act, s 400(1) applied: the Commission must not grant permission to appeal unless it is in the public interest to do so.
The worker raised five grounds, arguing among other things that the performance improvement plan did not judge everyone in his team equally, that any lack of suitability for the role was not his fault and should attract compensation, and that he wanted a fresh review because he was not convinced all the facts had been considered.
The Full Bench found no arguable case of appealable error. On the peer-comparison complaint, it observed that the first decision had
carefully considered the question of who might be the appropriate peers
the Full Bench, [2026] FWCFB 151
and that the worker
simply disagrees with factual findings that appear to us to have been comfortably open
the Full Bench, [2026] FWCFB 151
On the public interest test, the Full Bench was brief:
The case turns on its own facts.
the Full Bench, [2026] FWCFB 151
The matter was decided on the papers, without an oral hearing, with the consent of both parties, and the decision was handed down in Melbourne on 19 June 2026. With permission refused, the first-instance dismissal of the claim stands as the final determination.
What the decision confirms
The refusal applies the established position that a Full Bench looks only for an arguable case of appealable error, and that appeals from unfair dismissal decisions cannot proceed unless the public interest is engaged, for example where a case raises issues of general application or a manifest injustice. Mere disagreement with factual findings that were open to the decision-maker is not enough.
Why this matters for care and community services providers
The principle reaches every employer covered by the unfair dismissal regime, including disability, home care and community services providers. In this sector, performance concerns about support workers are often managed by coordinators or small back-office teams rather than dedicated HR staff, and disputes frequently come down to contested factual findings about warnings, improvement plans and comparisons between rostered workers across different clients and sites. This decision confirms that once the Commission has made those factual findings after a proper process, a dissatisfied party cannot obtain a second hearing simply because they disagree with the outcome.
How we support SCHADS employers
Unfair dismissal claims can expose employers to significant legal and operational risk. We help our clients build robust dismissal practices that protect both the organisation and the employee.
We support our clients by ensuring that:
- dismissal decisions are preceded by a fair process that gives the employee a genuine opportunity to respond to performance or conduct concerns
- documentation of performance or conduct issues is thorough and contemporaneous, supporting any decision to dismiss
- the reason for dismissal is substantive and the decision is not harsh, unjust or unreasonable in the circumstances
- procedural fairness is observed, including consideration of whether the employee has access to support or representation during any hearing
SCHADS Award questions? 1800 SCHADS are Australia’s SCHADS Award specialists. The first call is obligation free: a scoping conversation about where you stand on sleepovers, on-call work, broken shifts, classifications and wage audits. Call 1800 SCHADS (1800 724 237).
Source reference: [2026] FWCFB 151
A SCHADS question of your own?
The first call is obligation free, confidential, and with an actual SCHADS specialist.