Late general protections claim refused after aged care settlement
A former aged care worker who settled her unfair dismissal claim with her union’s help, then lodged a second claim over the same dismissal 297 days out of time, has been refused an extension by the Fair Work Commission. In a decision issued on 13 October 2026, Deputy President Hampton found no exceptional circumstances and dismissed the application ([2026] FWC 3623).
A settled dismissal, then a second claim
The worker had been employed by the aged care operator since 2 November 2018. She was dismissed on 27 August 2025 after the employer found three allegations of behaviour and misconduct substantiated, findings she disputes.
With the assistance of the Australian Nursing and Midwifery Federation (ANMF), she filed an unfair dismissal application on 17 September 2025, the last day of the 21-day period. That claim settled at a Member Assisted Conciliation on 22 December 2025, and the application was discontinued. Under the terms of settlement she agreed to:
release and forever discharge the respondent, its directors, employees, assignees or successors from any liability past, present or future from all claims, actions or proceedings arising out of the applicant’s employment and the cessation of that employment
Fair Work Commission, [2026] FWC 3623
Workers compensation and superannuation were excluded from the release.
On 11 July 2026 she lodged a general protections application under s.365 of the Fair Work Act 2009, the provisions that bar an employer from taking adverse action, such as dismissal, against a worker for a protected reason. She claimed she was dismissed for participating in industrial activities under ss.346, 347 and 348, pointing to an ANMF annual conference for workplace representatives and health and safety representatives. She later also said she was a health and safety representative who had tried to raise safety concerns.
297 days outside the limit
Section 366(1) of the Act requires an application of this kind within 21 days after the dismissal takes effect. The deadline fell at midnight on 17 September 2025, which put the 11 July 2026 lodgement 297 days late. An extension is available only in limited circumstances:
The FWC may allow a further period if the FWC is satisfied that there are exceptional circumstances, taking into account: (a) the reason for the delay; and (b) any action taken by the person to dispute the dismissal; and (c) prejudice to the employer (including prejudice caused by the delay); and (d) the merits of the application; and (e) fairness as between the person and other persons in a like position.
Fair Work Act 2009, s.366(2)
The worker said she understood the matters were being handled by the union on her behalf, and that she had not been clearly advised of the 21-day limit or the need to lodge an application personally. The employer argued there were no exceptional circumstances, that her explanation was neither factually consistent nor reasonable, and that she had been dismissed for her work performance and misconduct, not for attending a union event or raising safety concerns. The matter was determined on the papers, as the worker preferred.
No credible explanation for the delay
Deputy President Hampton found the worker had not shown a reasonable or credible explanation for the delay, and that reliance on representative error had not been made out. The correspondence she supplied confirmed only that the ANMF was instructed to make the unfair dismissal application. The Commission noted it has consistently held that following internal processes does not of itself explain a delay:
awaiting some form of administrative review (whatever that was in this case) would fall into the same category.
Fair Work Commission, [2026] FWC 3623
There was apparently contact with the union in June 2026, but no indication the worker regularly followed up during the delay. It was also unclear whether or how an extract from a medical certificate dated 5 August 2026, linked to a workers compensation claim, was meant to explain the delay.
On the merits, the Commission found there appeared to be some basis for a general protections case, while the employer had stated a comprehensive and plausible defence. It found considerable substance in the objection that the settlement had released the claim, with no reasonable basis put forward for setting the settlement aside. The employer did not claim prejudice, and fairness between applicants was neutral. Weighing the s.366(2) factors, the Deputy President was not satisfied exceptional circumstances existed and dismissed the application. Whether the settlement itself would have barred a second application over the same dismissal was left open.
The refusal is the rule, not the exception. An analysis of every late unfair dismissal claim finally decided in published decisions this year found 3 of 38 won a further period, a grant rate of 7.9 percent, and two of the three were just one day late.
What this means for SCHADS employers
The decision shows the Commission holding a settled dismissal dispute closed, even where the worker says she believed her union was still handling matters on her behalf. It confirms that a belief a representative is dealing with things, without regular follow-up, does not amount to exceptional circumstances justifying an extension, and that a signed release carries real weight when a second claim surfaces months later. That reasoning reaches any aged care, disability, home care or community services operation where a contested dismissal involves union representation and is resolved at conciliation.
How we support SCHADS employers
General protections laws protect workers from adverse action based on protected attributes and conduct. We help our clients build workplaces where these protections are embedded in everyday management practice.
We support our clients by ensuring that:
- employment decisions about hiring, promotion, pay and termination are based on genuine work-related factors and documented consistently
- managers understand which attributes and forms of conduct attract protection, and how to distinguish lawful performance management from unlawful adverse action
- complaints and concerns about potential breaches are handled promptly through fair processes that give affected workers a genuine opportunity to respond
- policies and procedures are applied uniformly so that similarly situated workers are treated the same way
SCHADS Award questions? 1800 SCHADS are Australia’s SCHADS Award specialists. The first call is obligation free: a scoping conversation about where you stand on sleepovers, on-call work, broken shifts, classifications and wage audits. Call 1800 SCHADS (1800 724 237).
Source reference: [2026] FWC 3623
A SCHADS question of your own?
The first call is obligation free, confidential, and with an actual SCHADS specialist.