Medical certificate citing difficulties fails to extend unfair
A late unfair dismissal application has been dismissed by the Fair Work Commission after the medical evidence offered to explain the delay described difficulties rather than any actual incapacity to lodge the claim. The decision, issued on 23 September 2026, confirms that an extension of the 21-day lodgement period requires exceptional circumstances, and that general statements about a worker’s health will not, on their own, meet that bar.
The worker lodged her application under s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 on 22 May 2026, saying her dismissal took effect on either 29 or 30 April 2026. The employer objected that the application was out of time and maintained the employment had in fact ended by resignation effective 28 April 2026. Commissioner Harper-Greenwell found that on any of those dates the application was filed after the 21-day period, so the extension question had to be decided before anything else. The matter was determined on the papers, with neither party asking to be heard.
The medical evidence
The applicant said the delay stemmed from her mental health, which she said was worsened by the dismissal and limited her ability at the time to handle paperwork, communicate and complete the application. She relied on a medical certificate dated 29 May 2026 stating she had difficulty coping with schedules and deadlines, affecting her ability to function effectively.
That was not enough. The Commissioner found the certificate
refers to ‘difficulties’ and does not detail any actual incapacity
Fair Work Commission, [2026] FWC 3652
and did not show the applicant’s health affected her capacity to the extent that it prevented her from lodging within the 21 days. Under the established test, circumstances need not be unique or unprecedented to be exceptional, but they do need to be out of the ordinary course, unusual or uncommon, whether through one exceptional matter or several ordinary factors combining.
The other factors
The remaining statutory considerations did not help the applicant either. The Commission found:
- she knew at the time the dismissal took effect that her employment was over, so the full 21-day period was available to her, which weighed against an extension;
- apart from filing the application itself, she had taken no other step to dispute the dismissal, which also weighed against her;
- prejudice to the employer, fairness compared with others in a like position, and the merits of the claim were all neutral, the merits because no evidence on the substantive dispute had been filed.
Weighing those matters, the Commissioner was not satisfied the circumstances were exceptional, individually or together, refused the extension and dismissed the application. Because the case ended on the jurisdictional point, the competing accounts of whether the employment ended at the employer’s initiative or by agreement were never tested. The parties had given very different versions: the worker said she was dismissed over absences linked to medical conditions after returning on 27 April 2026 with a certificate clearing her for light duties, while the employer said the separation was mutually agreed and that it paid out her notice period and entitlements at her request.
The outcome is consistent with the Commission’s broader approach. Of every late unfair dismissal claim finally decided in published decisions this year, 3 of 38 won a further period, a grant rate of 7.9 percent, and two of the three were just one day late.
What this means for community services providers
The principle is award-neutral and applies to all employers, including disability, home care and community services providers. When a dismissed or departing employee lodges an unfair dismissal claim outside the 21-day window, the Commission decides the timing question first, and vague medical evidence of difficulties will generally not secure an extension. For providers with casual and part-time workforces and high turnover, where separations are frequent and sometimes contested as resignation versus dismissal, the decision shows that a late claim can end at the jurisdictional stage without the underlying dispute ever being examined.
How we support SCHADS employers
Unfair dismissal claims can expose employers to significant legal and operational risk. We help our clients build robust dismissal practices that protect both the organisation and the employee.
We support our clients by ensuring that:
- dismissal decisions are preceded by a fair process that gives the employee a genuine opportunity to respond to performance or conduct concerns
- documentation of performance or conduct issues is thorough and contemporaneous, supporting any decision to dismiss
- the reason for dismissal is substantive and the decision is not harsh, unjust or unreasonable in the circumstances
- procedural fairness is observed, including consideration of whether the employee has access to support or representation during any hearing
SCHADS Award questions? 1800 SCHADS are Australia’s SCHADS Award specialists. The first call is obligation free: a scoping conversation about where you stand on sleepovers, on-call work, broken shifts, classifications and wage audits. Call 1800 SCHADS (1800 724 237).
Source reference: [2026] FWC 3652
A SCHADS question of your own?
The first call is obligation free, confidential, and with an actual SCHADS specialist.