Workplace bullying

QIRC declines to hear health service bullying grievance appeal

← Back to SCHADS news

The Queensland Industrial Relations Commission has declined to hear an appeal over a bullying and harassment grievance lodged against a senior finance executive at a Queensland hospital and health service. In a decision issued on 1 September 2026, Industrial Commissioner O’Neill found there was a compelling reason not to hear the matter: the executive had resigned in December 2024, so the outcome the grievance originally sought, an end to the worker having to report to him, had already come about ([2026] QIRC 270).

The grievance and what came before the appeal

The worker, a senior contracts lawyer who reported to the executive, lodged a grievance on 21 February 2024 alleging bullying and harassment, based on conduct spanning October 2023 to the middle of January 2024. The health service’s chief executive substantiated the allegations on 4 June 2024, but characterised the conduct as unprofessional conduct rather than bullying and harassment, found it breached the Code of Conduct seriously enough to warrant disciplinary action, and opted for management action instead of a disciplinary process. An internal review decided on 13 August 2024 that the outcome was fair and reasonable.

The worker appealed to the Commission on 2 September 2024. Weeks later, the health service announced to all staff that the executive had resigned and was moving interstate. His last day was 17 December 2024, the same day the State applied to have the appeal dismissed or not heard.

No practical utility left in the appeal

By the time the Commission decided the application, the executive had been gone from the workplace for 20.5 months, or 627 days, and the underlying events were some 2.5 to 3 years old. The State argued the appeal could no longer produce any practical result for the worker, who would neither be supervised by nor work alongside the executive on her return from leave, and that deciding the remaining grounds would be an academic exercise.

The worker maintained that five grounds stayed live, including procedural fairness complaints, the characterisation of the conduct as unprofessional rather than bullying, the adequacy of management action as a response, and an alleged conflict of interest in the original decision-maker. Industrial Commissioner O’Neill was not persuaded that any of them justified hearing the matter, finding:

the primary aim of the grievance was to obviate any requirement for the Appellant to have to work with [the officer]. That outcome has been well and truly achieved.

Queensland Industrial Relations Commission, [2026] QIRC 270

The Commission accepted that its discretion not to hear a public service appeal for a compelling reason can be exercised even where the grounds are arguable, and applied an earlier observation from its own case law:

For an appeal to warrant expending the time and resources of the Commission, it must produce a tangible result worthy of the use of those resources.

Queensland Industrial Relations Commission, quoted with approval in [2026] QIRC 270

Two further points decided

  • The public interest dismissal power did not apply. The State also relied on the Commission’s general power to dismiss proceedings that are not in the public interest, but the Commission held that power operates only in an industrial cause, and a public sector appeal brought under the Public Sector Act 2022 is neither an industrial cause nor an industrial matter. The public interest still fed into the discretion not to hear the appeal, just not as a standalone dismissal ground.
  • The Commission cannot discipline a former employee. On the worker’s contention that disciplinary action against the executive remained possible despite his departure, the Commission said it is not open to it to commence disciplinary action or make a disciplinary finding against him, and that any post-separation process was a matter for the chief executive’s discretion, separate from the appeal. The Commission also noted that a disciplinary pursuit at this stage would face challenges based on delay and the passage of time.

What this means for SCHADS employers

The decision shows a state tribunal treating utility as the threshold question in grievance appeals: once the person complained of has left, an appeal aimed at avoiding contact with that person can be closed even where the grounds are arguable. For public sector and state-system operations in aged care, disability, health and community services, it confirms that grievance and appeal pathways are directed at practical outcomes for the complainant, not at securing findings against a departed manager. It also illustrates that a tribunal hearing such an appeal has no power to impose discipline on someone who is no longer employed, a question that sits with the employing entity’s chief executive.

How we support SCHADS employers

Workplace bullying damages culture, retention and wellbeing across social and community services organisations. We help our clients build workplaces where respectful behaviour is the norm and concerns are handled fairly.

We support our clients by ensuring that:

  • clear conduct standards and values are communicated to all staff so everyone understands what respectful workplace behaviour looks like
  • managers and supervisors can recognise bullying behaviour and understand how to respond proportionately when concerns arise
  • staff have safe, accessible channels to raise concerns about bullying without fear of retaliation, and those reports are investigated fairly and promptly
  • workplaces have processes to support both affected staff and workgroups after bullying incidents, focusing on repair and prevention of recurrence

SCHADS Award questions? 1800 SCHADS are Australia’s SCHADS Award specialists. The first call is obligation free: a scoping conversation about where you stand on sleepovers, on-call work, broken shifts, classifications and wage audits. Call 1800 SCHADS (1800 724 237).

Source reference: [2026] QIRC 270

A SCHADS question of your own?

The first call is obligation free, confidential, and with an actual SCHADS specialist.

Call 1800 SCHADS Book a scoping meeting
Wage audits Sleepovers Classifications Self-Managed NDIS
← All SCHADS news

Start the conversation

Not ready to call? Leave your details and a SCHADS specialist will come back to you.