Labour hireUnfair dismissal

Union not liable for costs after unfair dismissal claim discontinued

← Back to SCHADS news

The Fair Work Commission has dismissed a labour hire employer’s bid for $1,874 in costs against a union after an unfair dismissal claim lodged for a Pacific Australia Labour Mobility (PALM) scheme worker was discontinued just 13 days after it was filed. In a decision issued on 14 September 2026, Deputy President O’Neill found the union had been authorised to bring the claim and that the costs application was directed at the wrong target ([2026] FWC 3488).

A claim filed, then quickly withdrawn

The unfair dismissal application was lodged on 16 June 2026 by the union on the worker’s behalf, with the form signed by one of the union’s employees. On 29 June 2026, three days after the employer filed its response, the union discontinued the matter, stating it had been advised the worker had left Australia and returned to Fiji.

On 10 July 2026 the employer applied for costs under s.401 of the Fair Work Act 2009, the provision dealing with costs against a lawyer or paid agent, naming both the union and the union employee who signed the claim. Of the $1,874 sought, $505 related to the costs application itself. A witness for the employer gave evidence that actual costs on the unfair dismissal application exceeded $3,000, with the costs application expected to add a further $4,000 to $6,000.

The wrong provision, and a missed window

At a mention, the Deputy President raised whether the application was competent at all, since neither the union nor its employee is a lawyer or paid agent for the purposes of s.401. The employer’s lawyers then sought to recast the application under s.611, which deals with costs against a party, and asked the Commission to waive the irregularity under s.586.

Timing proved decisive. Under s.402, a s.611 costs application in an unfair dismissal matter has to be made within 14 days of discontinuance, and only the original, misdirected application fell inside that window. The Commission accepted the amendment power was available because the recast application involved the same parties and grounds, but declined to exercise it, principally because the s.611 application would fail anyway, and because allowing the amendment would expose the union to a costs claim that could not otherwise be brought out of time.

The union had authority

The employer contended the union had acted without the worker’s authority, pointing to errors in the claim form and the absence of a termination letter. A former union organiser gave evidence that the worker had said at a meeting on 15 June that he felt his dismissal was unfair, had done nothing wrong and wanted help fighting it, and that termination letters are often not issued to PALM scheme workers. Deputy President O’Neill accepted the organiser as truthful and credible, and observed:

unlikely that a registered organisation who receives no fee for representing a union member in an unfair dismissal case would make an application without authority, at least absent cogent evidence of an ulterior or collateral purpose

Fair Work Commission, [2026] FWC 3488

No such evidence was before the Commission.

Costs orders bind parties, not their representatives

Applying established Full Bench authority, the Commission held that s.611 permits costs orders against a party, not the party’s representative, and that asserting a representative acted without authority does not transform the representative into the person who made the application. Neither limb of s.611(2) was made out: the claim was not made vexatiously or without reasonable cause, and it was not one with no reasonable prospects of success. Even where the costs power is enlivened, the Commission noted:

[w]hether costs are to be awarded at all, and the amount of any costs that are awarded, involves the exercise of a discretion

the Full Bench, [2023] FWCFB 147

The Deputy President concluded:

This is far from a clear case if a case at all, and in light of the evidence before me and the early discontinuance of the application, I would not order costs in any event.

Fair Work Commission, [2026] FWC 3488

The decision also noted that where a representative genuinely does file a claim without authority, other avenues of recourse may exist, particularly where the representative is a legal practitioner.

What this means for community services providers

The principle is award-neutral and reaches every employer, including disability, home care and community services providers, whose casual and part-time support workforces are among the most heavily unionised users of the unfair dismissal jurisdiction. Where a union lodges a claim for a member and later discontinues it, a costs order can only be sought against the worker as the party, not against the union that prepared the form, and only within the 14-day window after discontinuance. High turnover and transient workforces mean early discontinuances are a familiar feature of claims against providers, and this decision shows that an early withdrawal, on its own, does not open the door to recovering legal costs from the union involved.

How we support SCHADS employers

Unfair dismissal claims can expose employers to significant legal and operational risk. We help our clients build robust dismissal practices that protect both the organisation and the employee.

We support our clients by ensuring that:

  • dismissal decisions are preceded by a fair process that gives the employee a genuine opportunity to respond to performance or conduct concerns
  • documentation of performance or conduct issues is thorough and contemporaneous, supporting any decision to dismiss
  • the reason for dismissal is substantive and the decision is not harsh, unjust or unreasonable in the circumstances
  • procedural fairness is observed, including consideration of whether the employee has access to support or representation during any hearing

SCHADS Award questions? 1800 SCHADS are Australia’s SCHADS Award specialists. The first call is obligation free: a scoping conversation about where you stand on sleepovers, on-call work, broken shifts, classifications and wage audits. Call 1800 SCHADS (1800 724 237).

Source reference: [2026] FWC 3488

A SCHADS question of your own?

The first call is obligation free, confidential, and with an actual SCHADS specialist.

Call 1800 SCHADS Book a scoping meeting
Wage audits Sleepovers Classifications Self-Managed NDIS
← All SCHADS news

Start the conversation

Not ready to call? Leave your details and a SCHADS specialist will come back to you.